Two Women, Two Alabama Courts, Two Very Different Endings
Brittany Smith and Jacqueline Dixon both said they shot their abusers in self-defense. Only one walked free.
By Sue Hambrick · 6 min read · Law & Justice
Two Alabama cases, both involving women who claimed self-defense, ended in extremely different ways. The differences weren’t just about the verdicts, but also about the courts, communities, and circumstances. Both women said they were standing their ground.
Researcher Louise Snyder found that 67% of women serving time for murder in Alabama killed were people they accused of domestic or sexual violence. Yet, as Snyder noted, by 2018 Alabama courts had never allowed a single woman to use stand your ground as a defense.
Brittany Smith: Jackson County
Brittany Smith, a white woman in Jackson County, told police that a man she knew, Todd Smith (previous acquittance), became violent after she let him stay the night. She reported being twice raped and knocked unconscious. A rape crisis center documented 33 wounds, and a toxicology report found drugs and alcohol in Todd’s system. Her brother Chris, whom she called for and who came over first, told investigators that he shot Todd, but Brittany admitted the next day that she was responsible. She was arrested on a murder charge and held on a $100,000 bond.
In March 2018, Jackson County District Attorney Jason Rupert Pierce convened a grand jury, which indicted her for murder. At a hearing, Brittany testified that she shot Todd while he was holding her brother in a headlock and threatening to kill them all. Her brother had come to the house to confront Todd, who was accused of raping, strangling, and assaulting her earlier that night and threatening to kill her if she told anyone. Her lawyers argued she should be granted immunity under Alabama’s Stand Your Ground law because she feared for her life and her brother’s.
On February 3, 2020, Jackson County Circuit Judge Jenifer Holt rejected that claim. According to reports from AL.com and WHNT-TV, the court:
cited records alleging that Brittany tried to destroy evidence, and testimony that did not line up with medical evaluations and other evidence from the scene;
faulted her for inconsistent statements to police, including first saying her brother shot Todd, and questioned the extent of her brother’s injuries based on scene photos;
found that her injuries, which included neck bruising, bite marks, and a broken fingernail, did not reflect sexual assault by Todd;
said she could have fled to safety and did not need lethal force, and that her brother was also an aggressor because he brought a weapon and started the confrontation.
Jacqueline Dixon: Dallas County
In July 2018, Jacqueline Dixon, a Black woman from Selma, shot her husband, Carl Omar Dixon, during a confrontation in their front yard. She told police she acted in self-defense after he charged at her. Dixon was arrested and charged with murder, her bond set at $100,000.
Dixon had obtained a protection order against her husband in 2016 after he punched her in the face and verbally abused her multiple times. Dallas County District Attorney Michael Jackson said she had failed to seek enforcement of that order during the marriage. Which didn’t make sense: how is a woman supposed to enforce a protective order herself, when enforcement is the job of the police?
Jackson nonetheless sought a murder charge from the grand jury because, as he put it, “someone got killed.” Law professor Angela Davis notes that he had other options, including a lesser charge or no charge at all. Even with the evidence to get an indictment, she said, “the question is whether it’s the fair and right thing to do under the circumstances.” Alabama’s “Stand Your Ground” statute says a person is “justified in using physical force upon another person to defend himself or herself … from what he or she reasonably believes to be the use or imminent use of unlawful physical force by that other person.”
Why a Protection Order May Have Mattered
Both women said they acted to survive violence, but Dixon had something Smith didn’t: a protection order already on record. That may have provided the grand jury with state-validated evidence to weigh alongside her account. The reasons behind the grand jury’s decision aren’t public, so this is interpretation, not fact.
Even so, the order did not prevent her arrest. Dixon was charged with murder, with her bond set at $100,000, the same bond set in Smith’s case. If a woman with a documented protection order is still treated as a murder suspect first, the question is what a woman without one can expect. Huey and Lynch’s argument that Black women are too often seen as aggressive rather than vulnerable suggests that Dixon may have needed that paper trail more than a woman from a group that is more readily viewed as a sympathetic victim.
How It Ended
Case detail | Brittany Smith | Jacqueline Dixon |
County | Jackson County (rural, majority-white) | Dallas County (majority-Black, with a Black district attorney) |
Initial charge | Murder; indicted by a grand jury in March 2018; bond set at $100,000 | Murder; bond set at $100,000 |
Self-defense claim | Stand Your Ground immunity denied in 2020 | Stand Your Ground Immunity, Grand jury cleared her |
Final outcome | Facing up to 25 years, she accepted a murder plea deal in 2020: a 20-year split sentence (18 months in jail, 18 months of house arrest, and probation). | Cleared of all charges within three months of the shooting. |
Media Framing and Unequal Treatment
Despite clear evidence of abuse, Smith’s 33 wounds, Dixon’s protection order, police and prosecutors arrested and charged both women with murder. Neither case was initially treated as self-defense.
National advocacy and local resistance
In Dixon’s case, civil rights groups such as Color Of Change immediately framed her arrest around racial and gender disparities in Stand Your Ground laws, noting that Black women are rarely granted self-defense protections. Legal observers pointed out that Selma is in Dallas County, a majority-Black jurisdiction with a Black district attorney, when a local grand jury cleared her. Al.com reported the decision.
Smith was prosecuted in rural, majority-white Jackson County, where the judge scrutinized her credibility and past behavior. Her bond was later revoked over drug tests and probation violations. Her story became the subject of the Netflix documentary State of Alabama vs. Brittany Smith, which framed her ordeal around how Alabama’s self-defense laws fail survivors of domestic and sexual violence.
How writers discussed the contrast
Journalists covering Smith’s 2020 hearing, including at The New Yorker, explicitly linked the two cases. Smith herself had looked to Dixon’s 2018 exoneration as proof that an Alabama woman could successfully claim self-defense. That made it all the more striking when her own claim was rejected despite forensic evidence of rape and strangulation. After the ruling, her mother wrote on Facebook, “We all know that the Stand Your Ground Law was not created for women.”
Who gets a Netflix Special?
Smith’s case drew national attention and became a Netflix documentary. Dixon’s case was covered by outlets such as Al.com and championed by groups like Color Of Change, but it appears to have received far less sustained national attention. The court found that Smith’s early statements to police were inconsistent, and her case still became the better-known one.
Huey and Lynch argue that white women have historically been cast as the default face of sympathetic victimhood, rooted in ideals of “True Womanhood.” Whether that explains the media disparity here is open to debate—but it raises the question of why one story reached millions while the other relied on advocacy groups to be heard.
Final Thoughts
Both women had evidence of abuse, both claimed self-defense, and both faced murder charges—yet their outcomes diverged. The facts, courts, and public pressures all differed. These cases ask: Are Stand Your Ground laws applied evenly to women of different races?
Criminologists Jacklyn Huey and Michael J. Lynch note that stereotypes often portray Black women as aggressive, not as victims. Their research may help explain why Dixon’s case was so fraught, and why advocates saw it as a test of equal justice. But Smith’s case shows that gender bias can work against white women, too.
Sources and Further Reading
· Brittany Smith Loses Her Stand Your Ground Hearing — The New Yorker
· Tell Alabama DA: Drop the Charges Against Jacqueline Dixon — Color Of Change
· State of Alabama vs. Brittany Smith (Parents’ Guide and Movie Review) — Common Sense Media
· Brittany Smith Released From Alabama State Prison, Her Supporters Are Still Puzzled by Her Conviction — Local 3 News
· Jackson County Sentinel feature story — Jackson County Sentinel
· Alabama Woman Faces Life Sentence for Killing Man Who Allegedly Raped Her — The Appeal
· Penn State Dickinson Law Review article — Penn State Dickinson Law
· Jacklyn Huey and Michael J. Lynch, Race, Crime, and Justice: A Reader [pg 10]




Comments