Called for Help, Answered with Bullets: Policing on the Tohono O'odham Nation
Raymond Mattia called federal agents for help on May 18, 2023. That night, they came to his door and shot him. Allow me to set the scene.
The Night
Mattia was a 58-year-old member of the Tohono O'odham Nation, and he lived in the Menagers Dam community near the Arizona–Mexico border. Earlier that day, he had called Customs and Border Protection to report people crossing his property. That evening, tribal police got a report of gunfire nearby and asked Border Patrol to help. Agents arrived at Mattia's home.
Body camera footage shows Mattia stepping outside and tossing a sheathed machete toward a tribal officer's feet. Agents shouted at him to take his hands out of his pocket. When he did, they opened fire. The object in his hand was a cellphone. Three agents fired, and the medical examiner counted nine gunshot wounds.
In October 2023, the U.S. Attorney's Office declined to charge anyone. It said the agents' use of force "does not rise to the level of a federal criminal civil rights violation." Tribal leaders called the decision "a travesty of justice." His niece put it more simply: "My uncle was complying."
The Numbers Nobody Counts
Mattia's story is not rare. It's just rarely told. Campaign Zero data shows that Native Americans are about 3.2 times as likely as white Americans to be killed by police. Roughly 220 Indigenous people have been killed by law enforcement since 2013, at an average age of 33. CDC data from 1999 to 2014 put Native Americans' rate of police killings right alongside Black Americans', with each group taking the top spot depending on the year.
Even those numbers are probably too low. Federal crime reports often lump Native Americans into an "other" category, and police records rely on an officer's guess about someone's race. Most reservations have no local news outlet to cover a shooting, so many deaths never reach the national conversation at all.
Whose Law Is It Anyway?
Policing in Indian Country is a jurisdictional maze. About 70 percent of tribes depend on nearby non-tribal police or sheriff's departments. Since Oliphant v. Suquamish (1978), tribal courts generally can't prosecute non-Native people. Tribal courts also have no power over major felonies.
So on the Tohono O'odham Nation, federal agents shot a tribal member on tribal land, and the only office that could decide whether that was a crime was a federal one. The tribe had no say in its own justice. That is a big part of how Native communities experience policing: as something done to them by outsiders.
Outside the Paradigm
In class, we read Nancy Heitzeg's article on the criminalization of race. She writes that Native Americans and Latinos "are targets here too – but it is Blackness that provides the paradigm". She's right about the stereotype, but that framing has a side effect. When the public pictures police violence, Native victims don't fit the picture people already have. So they don't make headlines, they don't spark marches, and they don't show up in the data.
The Bottom Line
Raymond Mattia did what we tell people to do. He called for help, and he took his hands out of his pocket when ordered. He still ended up with nine bullet wounds, and no one was charged. For many Indigenous communities, the issue isn't only that police are dangerous. It's that the system was built so their deaths would go uncounted, uninvestigated, and unanswered.





Comments